home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=89TT2974>
- <title>
- Nov. 13, 1989: India:Puppies And Consumer Boomers
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1989
- Nov. 13, 1989 Arsenio Hall
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- WORLD, Page 53
- INDIA
- Puppies and Consumer Boomers
- </hdr><body>
- <p>A brash new middle class is stirring up social revolution
- </p>
- <p>By Edward W. Desmond/New Delhi
- </p>
- <p> Someone is knocking at India's door. No one special, just
- Ravi Khanna, a well-dressed young man who works hard and talks
- fast. But that unprepossessing exterior masks an agent of
- revolution, a force committed to arousing passions that are
- transforming India's tottering socialist order. "Good morning,
- Mrs. Bedi," Ravi says. "May I come in to show you the new
- Mitey-Vac? Is the man of the house in?"
- </p>
- <p> Before Mrs. Bedi knows it, Ravi is inside her small New
- Delhi apartment, demonstrating his wonder contraption. "Can it
- do cobwebs, spiders and lizards?" asks a wide-eyed Mrs. Bedi.
- "Anything," Ravi boasts. Mr. Bedi, however, is not impressed by
- the $200 price tag -- more than two weeks' wages for a
- senior-grade civil servant such as himself. "The cost is too
- much," he says. Ravi, sweating now, promises training, service,
- lifetime devotion. "For me," he says, "the customer is like a
- god." Mrs. Bedi looks expectantly at her husband, who walks out
- of the room muttering, "It's your choice."
- </p>
- <p> Ravi and Mrs. Bedi are only drops in the ocean of India's
- 835 million people, but they are part of a wave that has
- brought unprecedented change to India's economy and society over
- the past decade, and especially during the five years of Prime
- Minister Rajiv Gandhi's government. The participants in this
- social revolution are the members of India's middle class. A
- hardworking group with rupees to spare, they constitute a
- marketer's dream of as many as 200 million people, and are
- expanding rapidly. Ten years from now, predicts V.A. Pai
- Panandiker, director of New Delhi's Center for Policy Research,
- "about 300 million (Indians) will be members of the middle
- class."
- </p>
- <p> In India social position used to be equated with an English
- education and a job in the Indian Administrative Service. Today
- it is money that increasingly defines status, giving rise to a
- middle class that cuts across caste and region. The rush to
- acquire has affected such sensitive traditions as arranged
- marriages and has allowed middle-class women to emerge in the
- work force. It is no longer regarded as shameful to covet the
- good life and to seek an even better life for one's children.
- "Indians always accepted drudgery as what life had in store for
- them," says Mohammed Khan, chairman of Enterprise Advertising
- in Bombay. "Today self-gratification is no longer a dirty word."
- </p>
- <p> The urge to splurge has been fueled by several interlocking
- forces. Limited economic liberalizations instituted by Gandhi
- have freed the private sector to step up production. A wealth
- of consumer items now jam once poorly stocked shelves. Even
- those who cannot afford to buy the goodies are affected by the
- alluring images produced by India's upstart advertising industry
- and transmitted into the homes of the country's estimated 180
- million television viewers -- about 130 million more than five
- years ago. Those images, in turn, deepen middle-class
- dissatisfaction with the socialist restrictions that remain.
- "This is a greedy class, a demanding class," says Abid Hussain,
- a member of the Planning Commission in New Delhi. "It is crying
- out against the tyranny of the small inspector and the
- bureaucrat."
- </p>
- <p> But the capitalist outlook is still so new to India that no
- mainstream leader is quite ready to renounce socialism for the
- C word. Even Gandhi, who godfathered the middle-class surge,
- fears the fallout when less fortunate voters go to the polls
- later this month for parliamentary elections. For the past six
- months, he has turned his attention to promoting vast poverty
- relief and local rule schemes. Still, Gandhi's advisers say that
- if the Prime Minister is returned to power, he will push forward
- with deregulation and other reforms. If Gandhi is defeated, his
- successor may have little choice but to do the same. Says
- Surjit Bhalla, an economist with the Policy Group, a New Delhi
- think tank: "After what has happened in the past five years in
- the global economy, Indian policymakers have finally realized
- that socialism has failed to deliver the goods."
- </p>
- <p> Indian leftists counter that Gandhi is leaving India's vast
- numbers of poor people in the lurch. They argue that government
- resources are being diverted to help the well-off minority, who
- in turn are frittering away vital funds on luxury goods. Rajni
- Kothari, a widely respected social scientist, is worried that
- the middle class is dangerously insensitive to the desperately
- poor. Says he: "There is a disturbing decline in compassion, in
- charity, in pity."
- </p>
- <p> The consumer big bang was detonated in 1982 with the advent
- of color TV, but really took off in 1984 when Doordarshan, the
- monopoly state television company, began allowing advertisers
- to sponsor shows. Over the next five years, the advertising
- revenues at Doordarshan jumped more than tenfold. Top-rated
- shows exposed tens of millions of slum dwellers and villagers,
- as well as civil servants and professionals, to the
- blandishments of housewives, models and children. A surge in
- foreign travel and the arrival of the video revolution further
- whetted appetites for consumer goods.
- </p>
- <p> As a result, domestic manufacturing is soaring. From 1982
- to 1988, color television production jumped from 70,000 units
- a year to 1.3 million, while the output of black-and-white sets
- increased almost eightfold, to 4.4 million. Refrigerator and car
- production has also mushroomed, softening Indian resistance to
- borrowing. That means boom times ahead for a fledgling consumer
- finance business that, according to J. Rao, Citibank's chief
- executive officer in India, has skyrocketed from zero to $1
- billion in just three years.
- </p>
- <p> The rush to buy is rooted in the new middle class's love of
- ostentation. Many Indians consider those Punjabis who are most
- at home in Delhi to be particularly brash entrepreneurs and
- deride the type as the "puppy," for "prosperous urban Punjabi
- who is young." But where the consumer itch is involved, even
- ordinary Indians are not above one-upmanship. Onida, a
- television manufacturer, runs a national ad campaign with the
- slogan, "Neighbor's envy, owner's pride."
- </p>
- <p> The pursuit of a middle-class life-style is swiftly
- altering Indian society. While most marriages are still
- arranged, restrictions of caste compatibility are giving way to
- considerations of money. Marriage advertisements in newspapers
- often contain the phrase "caste no bar." Even more dramatic is
- the emergence of the working wife, once regarded by the middle
- class as a sign that her husband could not support his family.
- Today, says Medha Damle, manager of a Bombay matrimonial bureau,
- "99% of the men who apply want working girls. Most prefer girls
- with bank jobs, so (they) can get loans."
- </p>
- <p> Like their yuppie cousins in the West, Indian puppy couples
- are finding that the dual-income household can prove costly.
- Headlines in the newsmagazine India Today document the
- challenges: THE INDIAN MALE: MID-LIFE BLUES; MARRIED WOMEN:
- CHANGING SEXUALITY; DIVORCE: GETTING COMMON. The last reflects
- the clash of expectations in marriages in which the woman is now
- educated, assertive and independent. While a typical
- middle-class man wants a well-educated mate who works, he still
- expects his wife to run the house, look after the children and
- cater to his needs -- all without benefit of servants, who have
- become too expensive. Not unexpectedly, women find such demands
- unreasonable, and their quiet revolt is boosting the divorce
- rate.
- </p>
- <p> Middle-class angst, however, pales beside the miseries of
- India's poor. Free marketers argue that if economic growth
- reaches 7% or more, the "trickle down" will benefit the poor far
- faster than did four decades of socialist central planning. In
- the meantime, India remains divided between the barely
- subsisting poor and the consumer-happy middle class.
- </p>
- <p> An enormous national effort is necessary to reconcile those
- two worlds. The challenge for New Delhi is to provide
- education, health care and job opportunities to the poor, so
- they too can participate in India's revolution before resentment
- erupts among the have-nots. "You can view these changes as a
- great success," says an economist close to the Prime Minister's
- office, "or as the seed of a tremendous explosion." He adds, "I
- see both."
- </p>
-
- </body></article>
- </text>
-
-